Shelter Island Motels

The Official Guide to Shelter Island Motels – Your Trusted Source for the Best Stays!

Select dates
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Best Motels in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.3
Very good
620 Reviews

From

99$/night

Kenny'S Tipperary Inn

432 West Lake Drive

The 3-star Kenny'S Tipperary Inn Montauk is located 4.1 km from Deep Hollow Ranch and boasts a picnic area and a golf course.

Gosman's Dock is a mere 9 minutes' walk from the inn, and Fort Pond Bay Park is around 10 minutes' drive away.

The location will allow you to be 3.9 km from Shadmoor State Ocean Park.

Featuring blackout drapes and climate control, the air-conditioned rooms are also fitted with modern amenities such as a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. Bathrooms feature a separate toilet, a shower, and a rainfall showerhead along with a hair dryer and towels. The Kenny'S Tipperary Inn Montauk offers spacious rooms with views of the pool.

Read more
Check Availability

View all photos

7.6
Very good
472 Reviews

From

85$/night

Cheshire Welcome Inn

1106 South Main Street
Check Availability

View all photos

7.9
Very good
293 Reviews

From

70$/night

Carrier Motor Lodge

2660 Berlin Turnpike

Offering comfortable rooms, the comfortable Carrier Motor Lodge Newington hotel lies 3.7 km from Chesley Park. This 2-star motel provides Wi-Fi in the rooms.

When staying at the hotel, guests will be approximately 15 minutes by car from New Britain Museum of American Art.

Take benefit from the proximity to Webb-Deane-Stevens Museum, which is about 7 km away.

Each of the 12 rooms is equipped with an air conditioner as well as a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. The rooms here are fitted with private bathrooms. Offering a separate toilet and a shower, the bathrooms are also appointed with hairdryers and bath sheets.

Read more
Check Availability

Cheap Motels in Shelter Island

View all photos

8.4
Very good
246 Reviews

From

102$/night

Clinton Motel

163 East Main Street

Clinton Motel, located 10 minutes' drive from Hammonasset Natural Area Preserve, offers a seasonal outdoor pool and Wi-Fi in public areas.

The motel is located in a historical district, 1.6 km from Clinton Town Beach. The historic Allis-Bushnell House and Museum lies a 15-minute ride from this comfortable hotel.

The location will allow you to be within 4 km of Meigs Point Nature Center.

The 12 rooms include a seating area and a kitchenette equipped with an air conditioner to ensure guests' comfort. The rooms are fitted with private bathrooms. Bathrooms feature a separate toilet and a shower, along with comforts such as hairdryers and towels.

Read more
Check Availability

View all photos

9
Excellent
281 Reviews

From

285$/night

Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only)

20 S Elmwood Avenue

The 3-star smoke-free Aqualina Inn Montauk is located near the shopping district of Montauk, only 5 minutes on foot from Sunset Surf Shack. This Montauk motel offers Wi-Fi throughout the property, a car park on site and an outdoor swimming pool.

You'll be just 1.8 km from Lake Montauk and a short way from Saint Therese of Lisieux Church. The Aqualina Montauk offers proximity to natural sights like Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course (2 km) and the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach (2.8 km).

Kirk Park Beach is also situated merely 150 metres away.

A flat-screen TV with satellite channels, as well as coffee and tea making equipment, are offered in the allergy-friendly rooms. The private bathrooms have a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, along with comforts such as hairdryers and shower caps.

Read more
Check Availability

View all photos

7.9
Very good
210 Reviews

From

116$/night

Montauk Oceanside Suites

115 South Emerson Avenue

Situated 250 metres from Camp Hero State Park, Montauk Oceanside Suites hotel features a picnic area, barbecue grills, and a golf course.

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 2.7 km from this motel, and Star Island Yacht Club and Marina is a 10-minute drive from it. The 3-star hotel is 250 metres from Montauk bus stop and in close proximity to Air & Speed.

15 minutes by car from the Oceanside, guests will also find Deep Hollow Ranch.

Read more
Check Availability

Motels in Downtown Shelter Island

View all photos

7
Good
491 Reviews

From

71$/night

Red Roof Inn Milford - New Haven

10 Rowe Avenue
Check Availability

View all photos

7.7
Very good
333 Reviews

From

144$/night

Liberty Inn Old Saybrook

55 Springbrook Road
Check Availability

View all photos

7.4
Good
101 Reviews

From

65$/night

Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison

320 Boston Post Road

The 2-star Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison offers guests access to Madison Green Historic District, which is 4.8 km away.

The motel is located about 10 minutes' drive from Bishop's Orchards.

Guilford Art Center also lies 2.6 km away.

The bathroom features a separate toilet and a shower, along with hairdryers and bath sheets.

Read more
Check Availability

Shelter Island Extended Stay Motels

View all photos

8.7
Excellent
153 Reviews

From

250$/night

Southold Beach Motel

53250 North Road
Check Availability

View all photos

7.3
Good
360 Reviews

From

98$/night

Budget Host East End Riverhead

30 Lake Ave
Check Availability

View all photos

9.2
Excellent
55 Reviews

From

209$/night

White Sands Motel

28 Shore Road

The 3-star White Sands Motel Amagansett offers Wi-Fi throughout the property and free private parking on site.

The motel is around a 25-minute walk from Walking Dunes, merely 0.6 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Cultural sights in the area include Victor D'Amico Institute of Art, which is 550 metres away.

Located within 4 km of Hither Hills State Park, this oceanfront hotel puts the city at your fingertips.

The rooms at the White Sands provide guests with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, as well as comforts such as climate control. If you like cooking, there is a fridge and glassware provided on site. Featuring a separate toilet and a shower, the bathrooms also come with a shower cap and bath sheets. You can enjoy views of the sea from the rooms.

Read more
Check Availability

Weekly Motels in Shelter Island

View all photos

7.2
Good
230 Reviews

From

108$/night

Shorewood Inn

1399 Main Road

The 2-star Shorewood Inn Jamesport is just 5 minutes' walk from William Ris Gallery, featuring a picnic area, barbecue grills, and a golf course.

Attractions in the area also include the non-denominational Living Water Full Gospel Church, situated 3.9 km from this comfortable hotel.

An adjoining terrace and a balcony are featured in the allergy-free rooms for your convenience. The rooms also boast an electric kettle, a fridge, and glassware. Guests have access to a separate toilet and a shower, as well as bathroom comforts such as hairdryers and towels.

Read more
Check Availability

View all photos

6.8
Good
306 Reviews

From

70$/night

Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct

10 Bee Street

Conveniently located near restaurants, golf courses, and a concert hall, the family Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct offers a lift and a vending machine. This 2-star motel offers parking on site.

The historical tower "Castle Craig" is approximately 7 km from the hotel, while Meriden Green is around 10 minutes' drive away. It is 4.3 km from Indian Springs Golf Club.

Staying at the Red Roof Meriden, you can also enjoy natural sights such as Lyman Orchards, which is about 15 minutes away by car.

They offer bathrooms fitted with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet along with a hair dryer and towels.

Read more
Check Availability

View all photos

8.6
Excellent
125 Reviews

From

255$/night

Colonial Shores Resort

83 W Tiana Road

The beachfront Colonial Shores Resort Hampton Bays is located 4.3 km from Hot Dog Beach and has an outdoor swimming pool with a pool cover.

When staying at the 3-star motel, you'll be about 10 minutes by car from Good Ground Park.

The rooms are equipped with tea and coffee-making facilities, along with free Wi-Fi and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for guests' comfort. The air-conditioned rooms have private bathrooms fitted with a separate toilet, shower/tub combinations, and a shower/tub combination.

Read more
Check Availability

Hourly Motels in Shelter Island

View all photos

6.7
Good
148 Reviews

From

76$/night

Passport Inn And Suites - Middletown

1310 South Main St

The 3-star Passport Inn And Suites - Middletown offers access to Wadsworth Falls State Park, which is located around 10 minutes' drive away.

Dooley Pond Public Access in Middletown is just 1.6 km from the motel.

Brownstone Exploration & Discovery Park lies about a 15-minute drive from the property.

Some rooms also have views of the garden.

Read more
Check Availability

Location

Shelter Island, New York State, United States, 11954

Contact Us

YOUR DETAILS
SUBJECT
MESSAGE